MRT Operators Faced With A Catch-22

MRT Breakdown

On the very morning our earlier article, “Late Again? Oh MRT Delayed lor” was posted, a delay occurred on the North-South Line, what were the odds! To their credit, SMRT Corporation Ltd (SGX:C52) hasn’t been just idling around but they have been attempting to rectify the situation through capital expenditure (Capex) projects.

 

So What Has SMRT Done So Far?

Some projects include:

1)    Sleeper replacement works

2)    Resignalling of the NS and EW lines

More information on the sleeper replacement works can be found in this entertaining infograph!

 

Relationship Between MRT Fare & Expenses

MRT operators in Singapore were faced with a “catch-22”, on one hand they had to spend money for capital improvement projects while on the other hand they could not freely raise fares. A situation of diminishing profitability with your top line increasing at a slower rate than your expenses clearly didn’t help the cause!

 

Rev Exp Graph

 

 

Above is a simple illustration, although Revenue started at a higher base of S$100, it increased at a lower rate of 3% compared to 5% per year for expenses. Basically it would lead to Expenses (Red Line) overtaking Revenue (Blue Line) and it isn’t good when that happens. Red > Blue = Not Good

Hence the need for the “Rail Financing Framework”!

 

Has MRT Fare Increases Really Been Lagging SMRT’s Expenses?

SMRT Rail Bus

 

 

SMRT’s MRT and Bus operational data looked pretty grim. It appears that MRT operations are going along the direction that the Bus has taken, into the red. With Revenues (CAGR: 6%) rising at a slower rate than expenses (CAGR: 8%) it’s only a matter of time before Operating Profit arrives at a red figure if things stay the same. Says a lot for a transportation company when the bulk of operating profits are derived from rental and advertising.

In FY2014, S$94mil of SMRT’s operating profits were from Rental and Advertising while MRT and Bus generated operating profits of –S$23mil! The profits from Rental and Advertising were actually subsidising the transportation segments!

 

Let’s Take A Look At The MRT Adult Fare (Card) Increases

PTC Fare

 

All the above data are available on the Public Transport Council (PTC) website under Chronology of Fare Adjustments! If you are interested on the MRT fares for each respective MRT lines, they are also displayed on the PTC website under Distance Fares (Note: Rapid Transit System (RTS) stands for MRT).

 

 

MRT Fare Increase

 

 

Just from SMRT’s current base fare (Updated 6 Apr 2014) of S$0.77 and based on the S$0.12-0.18 increase, MRT base fares have just increased 18%-31% in 10 years of just a CAGR of 2-3% per year. Not that much when you place it in such a perspective!

 

Now To Correspond With SMRT’s Data

Some may say to the above point on base fares that most people might not travel such short distances for the base fares. Now let’s take into account the average fares one would pay per ride!

MRT Ridership

 

Well from the Revenue SMRT earns per ride, it actually seems like with the rebates, they have been held pretty constant in the last 4 years and even decreased from S$0.93/ride (2007) to S$0.88/ride (2014)!

This seemed to tally with the data that their Revenues in terms of fare raises wasn’t really pegged to their expenses!

 

Value In Action

From the above we can clearly see why a change is needed to the system, hence the introduction of the “Rail Financing Framework” to take the burden of capital improvements off the operators!

Another thing to take note of when researching is that we have to obtain data from multiple sources to see if they tally. In this case, we took the data from both SMRT’s public records and from the PTC to check the legitness of one’s claims!

 

Join us on Facebook for more exciting updates and discussion about value investing. Submit your email address for important market updates and FREE case studies!

Get our FREE monthly Asia In Focus report today

We will only provide you with information relevant to value investing. You can unsubscribe at any time. Your contact details will be safeguarded.The information provided is for general information purposes only and is not intended to be any investment or financial advice.

All views and opinions articulated in the article were expressed in Mun Hong’s personal capacity and do not in any way represent those of his employer and other related entities. Mun Hong does not own any shares in the companies mentioned above.

One thought on “MRT Operators Faced With A Catch-22

  • August 6, 2014 at 8:02 am
    Permalink

    I love reading through an article that can make people think.

    Also, thank you for permitting me to comment!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *